Because this was the first experience with submitting student work samples, all samples were initially accepted, regardless of the type or length of assignment. After assessment, faculty members discussed the following as part of a guided debriefing: The results of the assessment of critical thinking, in contrast, provided evidence that the outcome was practiced in each academic year of our curriculum, and performance levels increased as students progressed from matriculation to graduation. Using a high-quality rubric makes assessment, grading, and evaluation both easier and more precise. Ethical Reasoning is reasoning about right and wrong human conduct.

It is likely that users of this rubric will detect that the cell boundaries are permeable, and the criteria of the rubric are, to a degree, interrelated. This was the first time faculty members assessed ability outcomes across the curriculum in a comprehensive and systematic way. Skip to main content menu sign in. Further, research suggests that successful critical thinkers from all disciplines increasingly need to be able to apply those habits in various and changing situations encountered in all walks of life. However, because of the volume of work samples received initially, the primary investigator worked with the CCAC to determine:

This rubric provides the framework for evaluating both students’ developing relationship to texts and their relative success with the range of texts their coursework introduces them to. Because the VALUE rubrics have been previously validated, only minor wording modifications were made to better define terminology in the rubrics and to allow for improved applicability to a PharmD program Appendix 1Appendix 2.

The following approaches to data analysis were conducted. Beyond mere exposure to culturally different others, the campus community requires the capacity to: Brophy of the University of Florida. While demonstrating solid knowledge of the domain’s parameters, the creative thinker, at the highest levels of performance, pushes beyond those boundaries in new, unique, or atypical recombinations, uncovering or critically perceiving new syntheses and using or recognizing creative risk-taking to achieve a solution.


One major issue is the lack of a control group. First, yield was defined as the percent of student work samples that provided complete ability outcome scores. Further, research suggests that successful critical thinkers from all disciplines increasingly need to be able to apply those habits in various and changing situations encountered in all walks of life. Similarly, a student could receive low ratings, even if the team as a whole works fairly well.

Received Mar 1; Accepted Apr Support Center Support Center. Creating and Solivng Rubrics Concise overview of the key considerations of rubric construction. Written communication abilities develop through iterative experiences across the curriculum. After assessment, faculty members discussed the following as part of a guided debriefing: In addition, a description of the assignments with the instructions that initiated the student work would be vital in providing the complete context for the work.

Critical thinking is a habit of mind characterized by the comprehensive exploration of issues, ideas, artifacts, and events before accepting or formulating an opinion or conclusion.

None of the overall critical-thinking scores approached the maximum capstone score of 4.

Rubrics – Tarleton State University

Oral communication takes many forms. Faculty members considered use of the VALUE rubrics as a means of assessing program ability outcomes to be a worthwhile, authentic, and feasible means of program assessment to drive continuous quality improvement of the academic program. The student must have a strong foundation in the strategies and skills of the domain in order to make connections and synthesize.

aacu problem solving rubric

For this reason, while the rubric can be used if the assignments or purposes for work are unknown, it will work most effectively when those are known.

While Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education standards and guidelines stipulate the need for a comprehensive assessment plan that includes information about the attainment of student learning outcomes, 1 few of the many assessment efforts reported in the pharmacy literature track progressive student attainment of ability outcomes over the entire doctor of pharmacy PharmD program.


However, an area for improvement noted by assessors was the lack of diversity in student work samples tested during the calibration process. Of the 3 assessments, the 2 that most closely concurred were used. Samples were coded using an alpha-numeric coding system so that only the researchers knew the ability outcome being assessed and the course identification.

Several higher education institutions have used VALUE rubrics to assess the academic progress of their students.

VALUE Rubrics

The time and workload commitment was worthwhile because faculty members gained a shared understanding of critical-thinking and problem-solving abilities. Louis College of Pharmacy STLCOP initiated efforts to develop a set of program-level ability outcomes 14 general based solvign the LEAP outcomes 3 and 3 professional based on the Center for the Advancement of Pharmaceutical Education outcomes 11 and to delineate an authentic methodological approach to their assessment throughout the curriculum.

Perhaps the best fit for this rubric are those assignments that prompt the integration of experience beyond problme classroom.

aacu problem solving rubric

To achieve a baseline assessment of the curriculum, faculty members did not proactively design any practice opportunities or assignments in their courses to specifically address the VALUE rubrics. The superior scores solvihg the sixth-year students were accompanied by higher scores for all rubric criteria with the exception of influence of context and assumptions Figure 2.

RubiStar One of the oldest and most straightforward online custom rubric builder. Allen at Miami-Dade College. Accreditation standards and guidelines for the professional program in pharmacy leading to the doctor of pharmacy degree.