Case studies are useful but you should also include research into institutionalised children. From his survey of research on privation, Rutter proposed that it is likely to lead initially to clinging, dependent behavior, attention-seeking and indiscriminate friendliness, then as the child matures, an inability to keep rules, form lasting relationships, or feel guilt. According to the investigator she was living a simple lifestyle in a small private facility for mentally underdeveloped adults and appeared to be happy, and reportedly only spoke a few words but could still communicate fairly well in sign language. When Genie’s father reached adulthood, he changed his first name to one which was more typically masculine, and his mother began to spend as much time with him as she could. After a few months, the mother found that taking care of Genie was too difficult, and Genie was transferred to a succession of six more foster homes. By April and May , Genie’s scores on the Leiter International Performance Scale tests had dramatically increased, with her overall mental age at the level of a typical 4-yearmonth-old, but on individual components she still showed a very high level of scatter. There were a few primarily right hemisphere tasks Genie did not perform well on.
By the age of 4 years, 24 of the children had been adopted by foster parents, 15 had been returned to their natural families, and the rest remained in the home. Bowlby used the term ‘maternal deprivation’ to refer to separation from an attached figure, loss of an attached figure and failure to develop an attachment to any figure.
fhe His father forced his wife to keep him quiet, causing significant physical and linguistic developmental delays. When she was discovered she was severely undernourished, could not stand properly or walk normally, could not understand any language, and could not speak. Abused and neglected child studied by linguists.
Case Study of Genie (the feral child) by on Prezi
Her father beat her if she made anoise and he made violent, animal noises to her to keep her quiet. She invented her own system of gestures and pantomimed certain words as she said them, and also acted out events which she could not express in language. Archived from the original on November 7, No-one was allowed to speak to Genie.
Edexcel Psychology A2 – Child Psychology: Genie is a classic case study and has had a large amount pribation influence on the theories of privation.
Case studies in psychological research.
Over the following years multiple tests of her handedness supported this conclusion, as did observations of her in everyday situations. Throughout the time scientists studied Genie, she made substantial advances in her overall mental and psychological development. In Juneshe left the hospital to live with her teacher from the hospital, but a month and a half later, authorities placed her with the family of the scientist heading the research team, with whom she lived for almost four years.
The findings of the study were that the adopted children fared better than the ‘restored’ children in that they tended to form closer attachments to their adopted parents than the ‘restored’ children did to their natural parents.
As a result, he made a concentrated effort not to talk to or pay attention to her, and strongly discouraged his wife and son from doing so as well. Rigler acknowledged the proposed arrangement would clearly put him in a dual relationship with her, but Children’s Hospital and authorities decided that, in the absence of other adequate options, they would consent to making the Riglers Genie’s temporary foster parents.
I agree an advantage of using case studies is the vast amount of information collected. She spent many hours tied to a commode a chair with a potty and was fed baby food by her brother who was not permitted to talk to her.
Linguists also administered several brain exams specifically geared towards measuring Genie’s language comprehension. In particular, scientists have compared Genie to Victor of Aveyrona 19th-century French child who was also the subject of a case study in delayed psychological development and late language acquisition.
However, as you say a case like this is rare, this raises questions about its reliability and makes it very difficult to generalise. Playing with this and similar puppets quickly became her favorite activity and, apart from her tantrums, accounted for most of the few times she expressed any emotion during the early part of her stay.
Despite this she consistently deleted or substituted sounds, making her extremely difficult to understand. Although Genie’s mother later recalled that most of their casw during this time were shallow in nature, they continued to get along very well. She did make rapid improvement and learned to talk, to a degree, though she never managed to understand grammar and her privarion did not increase as much as might have been expected.
Because he believed Genie was severely retarded he thought she would require additional protection from him, and he therefore decided he needed to entirely hide her existence. I think that case studies could be improved if the studies were able to be replicated, so that the study is still insightful and detailed but also more researchers could study whether the results could then be generalised.
I believe that case studies are very useful within the Psychological approach as they study a specific behaviour in alot of detail, prvation is extremely useful when trying to provide practical applications for a piece of research to help people in society.
While Genie lived with the Riglers her mother usually met with her once a week at a park or restaurant, and their relationship continued to grow stronger.
Privation Case Study – Genie – Revision Cards in A Level and IB Psychology
Regardless of where she was she constantly salivated and spat, and continually sniffed and blew her nose on anything that happened to be nearby. Using all 4 key studies on this page will show depth to your knowledge. Years after the case study on Genie had ended, when somebody asked Susan Curtiss why they had not done so, Curtiss said she and the other scientists felt Lovaas’ methods of aversion therapy would have unduly limited Genie’s freedom and kept her from getting to the nurturing environment doctors and scientists sought for her.
Furthermore, although she could understand and produce longer utterances, she still primarily spoke in short phrases such as “Ball belong hospital”. Retrieved May 26, Prompted by this coincidence of timing, David Rigler led a team of scientists who sought and obtained a three-year grant from the NIMH to study Genie in May