Several examples of this can be seen in terms of the encroachment of industrial civilizations upon less developed and more traditional societies in various regions of the world. Is Jared Diamond’s thesis in Guns, Germs and Steel, a form of geographical determinism, historical racism, or just an explanation? There is at least one hint about a leading civilization destroying its own environment… but it is another story. Landes, The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: What makes its approach fresh is that the analysis is from someone who is neither an economist nor a historian. Retrieved March 14,

Large domestic animals such as horses and camels offered the considerable military and economic advantages of mobile transport. Skin color had nothing to do with it. Why does it matter what these oh so poor, less successful people look like? See all 15 questions about Guns, Germs, and Steel…. According to Diamond, it happened at the latrine.

While I might have been happier if the title had been Guns, Germs, and Seedsit remains a seminal look at the whys and wherefores of how some societies came to flourish, often at the expense of others.

He has dedicated this book to his sons and future generations. Although agriculture arose in several parts of yuns world, Eurasia gained an early advantage due to the greater availability of suitable plant and animal species for domestication.

jared diamonds thesis in guns germs and steel

Similarly, the differences between the current economies of North and South Korea, or between those of the former East and West Germany, cannot be attributed to the modest environmental differences between North and South Korea, or between East and West Germany. May 07, Rhiannon rated it it was ok Shelves: Other advanced cultures developed in areas whose geography was conducive to large, monolithic, isolated empires, without competitors that might have forced the nation to reverse mistaken policies such as China banning the building of ocean-going ships.


First off, he calls the indigenous naive like the extinct megafauna of the previous chapter – I’m not kidding, he uses that exact word and that exact comparison to animals; for somebody who’s so avowedly anti-racist that’s tgesis fucking awful rhetorical tactic – but the academic offense is that grrms primary sources for the capture of Inca leader Atahuallapa are, as far as I can tell, Spanish letters to the king and Spanish personal journals.

There is actually considerable climatic variation within a large area of east-west latitude and this includes the contrasts between the rainy verdure of western Europe and the continental extremes of central Asia There was a bunch abd special pleading and some downright nuttiness.

Independent News and Media Limited. The Evolution of Human Gund.

Diamond’s book Collapseis also amazing. Diamond described this idea on his next book, Collapse. In his last book published inthe anthropologist and geographer James Morris Blaut criticized Guns, Germs, and Steelamong other reasons, for reviving the theory of environmental determinismand described Diamond as an example of a modern Eurocentric historian.


Coming back to the main themes of the book: German as well as French geography provides geese and frogs. It’s an excellent, thought-provoking book. They’re only going to get worse, too. Detailed review to follow! Diamond identifies six criteria including the animal being sufficiently docile, gregarious, willing to breed in captivity and having a social dominance hierarchy. Thexis assumes that the areas with the largest populations and highest inter-societal competition gave rise to the fastest rate of technological development.


jared diamonds thesis in guns germs and steel

The histories of Australia and New Guinea Ch. I’m not sure I jardd that why the Spanish obliterated the Mayans instead of visa versa is the most interesting question of human history. View all 24 comments. A short history of everybody for the last 13, years is a transdisciplinary non-fiction book by Jared Diamondprofessor of geography and physiology at the University of California, Los Angeles UCLA.

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies

United States portal s portal Books portal History portal. For instance, when about to describe the meeting of the conquistador Pizarro with the Incan emperor Atahuallpa, he says: Jan 23, Deborah rated it liked it. One objection you could make is that it wasn’t luck, but rather that Europeans were more enterprising than people in other areas about finding good species to domesticate.

Unfortunately his story-telling abilities are so compelling that he has seduced a generation of college-educated readers.

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond

Take his chapter on the Spanish invasion of the Americas. But as he came to know and appreciate the many native people he met in his work, the question asked by a New Guinean named Yani remained with him. Don’t believe the hype. Norton in March To discuss the entirety of such a debate is beyond the scope of this paper.